- Qintar
- Calculators
- Gold exchange calculator: old gold for new
Gold exchange calculator: swapping old gold for new
In Egypt it is common to trade old jewelry in for new, often before a wedding. Enter what you handed over, what you received and any money that changed hands. The calculator values the old gold at the buy price and the new gold at the sell price with the making charge and its VAT, and shows what the fair difference was against what happened. The numbers update as you type.
Buy and sell, from the shop's side: the sell price (بيع) is what you pay a goldsmith; the buy price (شراء) is what the goldsmith pays you. The making charge (مصنعية) is the shop's fee for the work, per gram, and Egypt charges 14% VAT on the making charge only.
Result
| Value of the old gold at the buy price | |
| Goldsmith's deduction on the old gold | |
| Value of the old gold after the deduction | |
| Gold value of the new piece at the sell price | |
| Making charge | |
| 14% VAT on the making charge | |
| Total for the new piece |
Is exchanging old gold for new allowed in Islam? The religious view in brief
Egypt's Dar al-Ifta allows exchanging old worked gold for new with the difference paid, because worked gold is treated as a commodity (fatwa no. 4821 of 2004 and no. 7249 of 2009). Some scholars advise the more cautious way: sell the old, take its price, then buy the new in a separate deal. Either way you need the value of the old and the new in numbers, which is what the calculator does. If in doubt, ask a fatwa authority you trust.
Calculations are for information only. They are not financial advice or a religious ruling.
How the calculator works
- Value the old gold: Weight in grams × today's buy price for its karat, minus the goldsmith's deduction if any. This is what the goldsmith should credit you.
- Value the new gold: Weight in grams × today's sell price for its karat, plus the making charge (weight × making charge per gram), plus 14% VAT on the making charge.
- Subtract the two: Fair difference = value of the old − value of the new. If it is positive, you should receive it; if negative, you should pay it.
- Compare with what happened: What you actually received or paid against the fair difference. The gap between them is what you gained or lost, and its share of the value of the new gold gives the verdict.
The deal counts as fair if the gap is within 2% of the value of the new gold (or at least EGP 200), and clearly against you if the gap is more than 8%. Prices come from the Qintar app when the page opens, and you can type the goldsmith's own prices instead. The full explanation, with a real example at real prices, is in the guide swapped old gold for new: was it a fair deal?.
Common questions
At what price does the goldsmith take my old gold?
At the day's buy price for its karat, the price at which the goldsmith buys from you, which is lower than the sell price you pay when you buy. Some goldsmiths also deduct a percentage from old gold for wear, so ask for it as a number and enter it in the deduction field.
Do I get the making charge back when I exchange?
No. The goldsmith buys gold by its weight and karat, not for the work in it, so the old making charge is lost. On the new piece you pay a new making charge, with 14% VAT charged on the making charge only, not on the gold price.
The same calculator is in the Qintar app with live prices, together with buy and sell prices for 24K, 21K, 18K and silver, your holdings at today's price, and the zakat calculator. Free and with no ads.
Prices and calculations are for information only. They are not financial advice, an offer to buy or sell, or a religious ruling.