Qintar
  1. Qintar
  2. Guides
  3. Swapped old gold for new at an Egyptian goldsmith: was it a fair deal?

Swapped old gold for new at an Egyptian goldsmith: was it a fair deal?

Published November 17, 2026 · By the Qintar team

A question we hear often: "I had two bangles weighing 35 g. I swapped them for two new bangles weighing 32.49 g, and the goldsmith gave me EGP 500. Was that fair, or was I cheated?" The answer is not "fair" or "unfair" without numbers. An exchange is really two deals in one: a sale of the old gold and a purchase of the new. Once you separate them with numbers, you know what the fair difference was and can compare it with what actually happened.

Swapping old jewelry for new is very common in Egypt, often before a wedding or when a design goes out of fashion, so it is worth knowing how the goldsmith does the sum.

How an exchange works at the goldsmith

How to read an Egyptian gold price list. Prices are written from the shop's side. Sell (بيع) is what the shop sells to you for, so it is what you pay. Buy (شراء) is what the shop pays you when you sell. The sell price is always the higher one.

The goldsmith takes your old gold by weight and karat and values it at the day's buy price, the price at which he buys from you, which is lower than the sell price you pay when you buy. Many goldsmiths also deduct a percentage from old gold for wear or damage; this is usually said out loud and rarely written down. The making charge you paid long ago for the old piece is not returned: the goldsmith buys the gold, not the work.

Then he gives you the new piece at the day's sell price, plus the making charge in EGP per gram, plus 14% VAT on that making charge. The VAT is on the making charge only, not on the gold. So what you pay for the new piece is: the gold + the making charge + its VAT.

The calculation in four steps

  1. Value of the old: weight × the buy price of its karat, minus the goldsmith's deduction if any.
  2. Value of the new: weight × the sell price of its karat, plus the making charge (weight × making charge per gram), plus 14% of the making charge.
  3. The fair difference: value of the old minus value of the new. If the result is positive, you should receive money; if it is negative, you should pay.
  4. Compare: what you actually received or paid against the fair difference. The gap between them is what you gained or lost on the deal.

To get it right you need the weight and karat of both. The hallmark (دمغة) tells you the karat, and the invoice proves the weight and the making charge. If you were told the weight of the old gold without seeing it weighed, ask for it to be weighed.

A real example: 35 g old for 32.49 g new and EGP 500

Here is the question above, worked out with Qintar's prices of 3 November 2026: 21K buy EGP 6,160.25 per gram and sell EGP 6,180.25. Both pieces are 21K. The making charge on the new piece is an assumption of EGP 120 per gram, because the question does not say, and there is no deduction on the old gold.

ItemCalculationEGP
Value of the old35 × 6,160.25215,608.75
Gold value of the new32.49 × 6,180.25200,796.32
Making charge (assumed)32.49 × 1203,898.80
14% VAT on the making charge3,898.80 × 0.14545.83
Total for the new200,796.32 + 3,898.80 + 545.83205,240.95
Fair difference (you should receive)215,608.75 − 205,240.9510,367.80
What happenedReceived500.00
Gap500 − 10,367.80−9,867.80 (about 4.8% of the new)

So with these numbers, about EGP 10,400 should have come back to you, and you got 500. In pure gold: you handed over 30.63 g and received 28.43 g, a difference of 2.20 g of pure gold.

So was the EGP 500 fair?

With the assumptions above, no: you received about EGP 9,900 less than your due. But two things could bring the numbers closer. First, the goldsmith may have deducted from the old gold: a deduction of about 4.5% for wear would make the 500 close to fair. Second, the making charge may have been higher than 120: for the 500 to be fair with no deduction, the making charge would have to be about EGP 385 per gram, which is high for ordinary jewelry.

The bottom line: if the goldsmith did not say he was deducting from the old gold, and did not quote a making charge of that size, the gap is not in your favor. If he did, the comparison is clear and the decision is yours. That is why you should ask before you agree: how much per gram for the old? How much per gram for the new? What is the making charge? Then do the sum in the gold exchange calculator while you are still in the shop.

The religious view on exchanging gold

Egypt's Dar al-Ifta allows exchanging old worked gold for new with the difference paid, because worked gold is treated as a commodity (fatwa no. 4821 of 2004 and no. 7249 of 2009). Some scholars, including some at al-Azhar, advise the more cautious way: sell the old gold and take its price, then buy the new piece in a second, separate deal. Neither "forbidden" nor "allowed" applies without detail; both views exist, and what they share is that you must know the value of the old and the new in numbers before you exchange. If in doubt, ask a fatwa authority you trust.

Before you exchange: a quick checklist

Common questions

At what price does the goldsmith take my old gold?

At the day's buy price for its karat, the price at which the goldsmith buys from you, which is lower than the sell price you pay when you buy. Some goldsmiths also deduct a percentage from old gold for wear, so ask for it as a number before you agree.

Do I get back the making charge I paid on my old gold?

No. The goldsmith buys gold by weight and karat, not for the work in it, so the old making charge is lost. On the new piece you pay a new making charge, with 14% VAT charged on the making charge only.

Is exchanging old gold for new allowed in Islam?

Egypt's Dar al-Ifta allows exchanging old worked gold for new with the difference paid, because worked gold is treated as a commodity (fatwa no. 4821 of 2004 and no. 7249 of 2009). Some scholars advise the more cautious way: sell the old, take its price, then buy the new in a separate deal. Either way, know the value of both in numbers. If in doubt, ask a fatwa authority you trust.

Want to check your own deal? Open the gold exchange calculator: enter the weight of the old and new gold, the karat, the making charge and what you received or paid, and it shows what the fair difference was at today's prices. The same calculator is in the Qintar app with live prices, free and with no ads.

Read next

Sources

The rulings and rates on this page come from the bodies listed. Check them before any financial or religious decision that concerns you.

Prices and calculations are for information only. They are not financial advice, an offer to buy or sell, or a religious ruling.