Comparing gold suppliers: the real making charge
The making charge a supplier quotes is not always what you pay: one supplier gives a discount for cash, another gives time to pay, and a third accepts returns.
To compare fairly, work out the effective making charge after the discount, and multiply it by the weight of the order you will actually place.
Payment terms have a value, especially if your cash is limited. The sheet writes them next to the figure so you do not forget them.
Quality, keeping to delivery dates and returns are not numbers, but they matter. Record them in the notes.
How shops buy from suppliers in Egypt
A retail gold shop buys finished jewelry from wholesalers and workshops. The gold in the pieces is usually settled by weight or at the market price, so the part that differs from one supplier to the next is the making charge per gram.
That is why the sheet compares making charges only. The gold would cost much the same from any supplier; the making charge, the discount and the terms are where the offers really differ.
The example in plain words
The shop wants a 500 g order of 21K. Supplier A asks EGP 65 a gram with no discount, gives 30 days to pay and accepts returns within a week: EGP 32,500 for the order.
Supplier B asks EGP 70 a gram but gives a 10% discount, so the effective rate is EGP 63 and the order costs EGP 31,500, cash only. Supplier C asks EGP 60 a gram with 15 days to pay: EGP 30,000.
On the numbers alone, Supplier C is cheapest. Whether A's 30 days and its returns are worth paying more for is a decision the sheet leaves to you.
The calculation
- Effective making charge per gram = making charge per gram × (1 − discount).
- Total making charge for the order = effective making charge × order weight.
- Payment terms, returns and quality are not in the figure: compare them yourself.
Example A worked example
Order weight, g (example): 500.000
| Supplier | Making charge per gram | Discount % | Payment terms (days) | Effective making charge per gram | Total making charge for the order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example: Supplier A | 65.00 | 0.0% | 30 | 65.00 | 32,500.00 |
| Example: Supplier B | 70.00 | 10.0% | 0 | 63.00 | 31,500.00 |
| Example: Supplier C | 60.00 | 0.0% | 15 | 60.00 | 30,000.00 |
Figures marked "Example" are for illustration, and the prices are approximate as of the date the sheet was made. Type your own figures in the sheet or the calculator.
Terms used on this sheet
- Supplier
- The wholesaler or workshop that sells finished jewelry to a shop (مورد).
- Making charge
- The fee for the work, per gram (مصنعية). Between shop and supplier it is usually settled in pounds, while the gold is settled by weight.
- Payment terms
- How many days the supplier gives you to pay. Zero means payment on delivery.
- Effective making charge
- The making charge per gram after the discount: what you really pay.
Step by step with the sheet
- The order: The weight you are comparing on.
- The offers: The making charge, discount and payment terms of each supplier.
- The calculation: The effective making charge and the total.
- The notes: Returns and delivery.
- The decision: The numbers together with the terms.
The sheet is free: Comparing suppliers: which making charge is cheaper? (Excel and PDF), or try it online with today's prices.
Frequently asked questions
Does the sheet put a value on the payment terms?
No. The payment terms are written next to the figure so you can compare them, but they are not part of the calculation.
Is the gold itself included?
No. The comparison is on the making charge only, because the gold is settled by weight or at the market price.
What is the discount taken from?
From the making charge. If a supplier discounts in a different way, change the formula.
Why compare on the same order weight?
Because the total in pounds is what you will pay. A difference of a few pounds per gram becomes a real sum on hundreds of grams.
Prices and calculations are for information only. They are not financial advice, an offer to buy or sell, or a religious ruling. Check tax matters with your accountant.
Live prices in the app. The Qintar app shows gold and silver buy and sell prices in Egypt, your holdings at today's price, and a zakat calculator. Free, with no ads.