# Gold, certificates or dollars? Compare your own numbers

> Enter an amount, a period and the rates to try, and see a gold, bank certificate and dollar scenario in numbers, costs included and with no forecast.

Source: https://qintar.app/en/tools/gold-vs-certificates-vs-dollar.html
Language: English
قنطار (Qintar)، qintar.app

---

# Gold, bank certificates or dollars? Compare with the numbers you enter

A comparison with numbers you enter, not a forecast: one amount and one period, and the result for each option.

This calculator does not forecast or advise: it works out a scenario from the numbers you enter. Enter the amount and the period, the certificate return you have in mind, and the gold and dollar change you want to test, and see the result for each option. The gold rate is filled in with what actually happened over the last year, and the certificate return is left empty for you to enter.

## Result

| Option | Final value | Gain or loss | Effective yearly rate |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |

The results come only from the numbers you entered. The real change in gold and the dollar is not known in advance. Certificates have the bank's terms. Gold has the buy/sell gap and the making charge, and both are included in the calculation.

## How the calculator works

1. **Work out gold:** Grams of gold = amount ÷ (sell price + making charge × 1.14). After the period they are valued at the buy price: buy price × (1 + gold change) to the power of the years, so the buy/sell gap is counted on the way out.
2. **Work out the certificate:** Final value = amount × (1 + return) to the power of the years, compounded yearly. It appears once you enter the return.
3. **Work out dollars:** Final value = amount × (1 − spread) × (1 + dollar change) to the power of the years × (1 − spread). The spread is assumed at 1% when buying and when selling.
4. **Get the gain and the yearly rate:** Gain = final value − amount, and the effective yearly rate = (final value ÷ amount) to the power of (1 ÷ years) − 1.

## What exactly does the calculator do?

It takes one amount and one period and works out three scenarios for the same money: if it were turned into gold, put in a bank certificate (شهادة, a fixed-term savings product in Egyptian pounds), or turned into US dollars. The result depends on the rates you enter: the gold change, the certificate return and the dollar change. There is no number from us except the one clearly filled in as an example: the gold rate is filled in with what actually happened over the last 365 days in Qintar's data, as a starting point, and you can delete it and enter another.

## What the numbers tell you

Each row shows the value at the end of the period, the gain or loss in EGP and percent, and the effective yearly rate. Gold has two costs taken from day one: the making charge and tax when you buy, and the gap between the sell and buy price when you sell, and both are counted here. Dollars pay no return, and the buy/sell spread is counted as a small assumed percentage. The certificate's return is fixed at the stated rate, but check the bank's terms: the period, when the return is paid, and the penalty for breaking it early.

## What is not included, and what is unknown

Most important: future changes in the gold price and the dollar are unknown, and any rate you enter is a scenario, not a forecast. What happened last year does not guarantee what comes next. Also not included: inflation (what a fixed return is worth against rising prices), any tax on the return, and storing and insuring gold. Try several rates in each field and see the difference, because the answer changes with the period and with the rates you assume. For the full explanation, read [gold, certificates or dollars: how to compare with numbers](https://qintar.app/en/articles/gold-vs-certificates-vs-dollar.html).

## An example of how to use it

Leave the certificate return empty at first and look at gold alone at last year's rate, then enter the return of the certificate you are considering and see the two rows side by side. Then change the period from one year to five and notice that the order can change. Try a gold rate lower than last year's, then zero, then negative, to see the picture from more than one angle. And do not forget to check the certificate's terms with the bank itself.

In the end, the calculator answers only one question: "if this happened, what would I end up with?" Whether it will happen, nobody knows; you choose the rates to try and look at the picture they give.

## Common questions

**Does the calculator tell me what to buy?**

No. There is no forecast and no recommendation: the calculator works out a scenario from the numbers you enter and shows the result of each option for the same amount and period.

**Why is the gold rate filled in from last year?**

Because it is a real figure from Qintar's data for the last 365 days, a starting point to try. It is what happened, not a forecast, and you can delete it and enter any other rate.

**Why is gold valued at the buy price at the end?**

Because when you sell you get the buy price, not the sell price. The calculator models a realistic exit, so the buy/sell gap and the making charge are included.

**What should I enter for the certificate return?**

The yearly return written on the bank certificate you are considering. The calculator does not fill in a figure, because returns and their terms differ from bank to bank.

**The same calculator is in the Qintar app** with live prices, together with buy and sell prices for 24K, 21K, 18K and silver, your holdings at today's price, and the zakat calculator. Free and with no ads.

[Open the web app](https://qintar.app/app/) [Get it on Google Play](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=app.qintar)

## More from Qintar

- [Gold, bank certificates or dollars? How to compare](https://qintar.app/en/articles/gold-vs-certificates-vs-dollar.html)The comparison method, with no forecast.
- [Gold break-even calculator](https://qintar.app/en/tools/gold-break-even-calculator.html)If you sold your gold now.
- [The goldsmiths' dollar explained](https://qintar.app/en/articles/goldsmith-dollar.html)The official dollar against the goldsmiths' dollar.
- [All gold and silver calculators](https://qintar.app/en/tools/)Every Qintar calculator on one page.

Prices and calculations are for information only. They are not financial advice, an offer to buy or sell, or a religious ruling.
