# Saving in silver monthly: average cost and making charge

> How to track saving a fixed amount in silver each month: grams after the making charge and VAT, pure silver, average cost and value at today's price.

Source: https://qintar.app/en/articles/silver-monthly-savings.html
Language: English
قنطار (Qintar)، qintar.app

---

If I put an amount into silver every month, how much pure silver do I build up, and what is my average cost?

Silver is far cheaper than gold, so many people start saving in it with small amounts. But the making charge is a large share of its price.

That is why grams = the amount ÷ (the silver price for its fineness + the making charge and its VAT). Jewelry carries a higher making charge than bars.

Compare your average cost per gram with today's buying price to see where you stand on paper.

The sheet only calculates. The decision is yours, and prices can go up or down.

## Why silver savers watch the making charge

On gold, the fee on a bar is a small fraction of the gram price. On silver, at the example price of EGP 88.08 a gram, even a small making charge per gram, with its VAT, is a noticeable share of every purchase.

That is why the sheet asks for the making charge on every line, and why bars of 999, with their low making charge, are the simplest case to follow.

## The example in plain words

The saver puts EGP 3,000 into 999 silver in September, October and November, at EGP 79.50, 84.20 and 88.08 a gram, with a making charge of EGP 6 a gram. The three months buy 34.746 g, 32.953 g and 31.606 g.

After EGP 9,000 the saver holds 99.304 g (99.205 g of pure silver) at an average cost of EGP 90.63 a gram. At a buying price of EGP 88.08 that silver is worth EGP 8,746.74 today: a paper loss of EGP 253.26, because the average cost, with the making charge and VAT, is above today's buying price.

## The calculation

- Grams this month = amount ÷ (price of 1 g of 999 × fineness ÷ 999 + making charge × (1 + VAT)).
- Pure silver = grams × fineness ÷ 1000.
- Value today = grams × fineness ÷ 999 × today's buying price of 1 g of 999.

## Example A worked example

VAT on the making charge, as on your invoice (example): 14% · Today's buying price, 1 g of 999 silver (example): 88.08

| Month | Price of 1 g of 999 on the day | Amount | Grams bought | Pure silver (g) | Worth today |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Example: September | 79.50 | 3,000.00 | 34.746 | 34.712 | 3,060.46 |
| Example: October | 84.20 | 3,000.00 | 32.953 | 32.920 | 2,902.46 |
| Example: November | 88.08 | 3,000.00 | 31.606 | 31.574 | 2,783.82 |

| Result | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Total grams | 99.304 |
| Total pure silver | 99.205 |
| Total paid | 9,000.00 |
| Average cost per gram | 90.63 |
| Value at today's buying price | 8,746.74 |
| Paper gain / loss | −253.26 |

Figures marked "Example" are for illustration, and the prices are approximate as of the date the sheet was made. Type your own figures in the sheet or the calculator.

## Terms used on this sheet

- **999 silver:** Silver of 999 parts per thousand, almost pure. Bars are usually 999.
- **Fineness:** The silver content in parts per thousand; 925 means 92.5% silver.
- **Making charge:** The fee per gram for the work (مصنعية). On silver it is a large share of the price.
- **Buying price:** The price at which a shop buys silver from you. Your silver is valued at this price.

## Step by step with the sheet

1. **The month:** The price, the fineness, the making charge and the amount.
2. **The grams:** After the making charge and its VAT.
3. **Pure silver:** The pure silver you hold.
4. **The average:** Total paid ÷ grams.
5. **The value:** At today's buying price.

**The sheet is free:** [Monthly silver savings plan](https://qintar.app/en/sheets/silver-savings-plan.html) (Excel and PDF), or [try it online](https://qintar.app/en/tools/silver-savings-plan.html) with today's prices.

## Frequently asked questions

**Why does the making charge matter so much on silver?**

Because a gram of silver is cheap, the making charge per gram is a large share of its price. Bars carry a lower making charge than jewelry.

**Is this advice to save in silver?**

No. The sheet works out a plan you chose. Prices go up and down.

**What VAT rate do I type?**

The one on your invoice. The 14% in the example is an illustration.

**Why can the example show a loss even though prices rose?**

Each purchase paid the making charge and its VAT on top of the silver, while the value is counted at the buying price of the metal alone. The price has to rise by more than that before the paper result turns positive.

Prices and calculations are for information only. They are not financial advice, an offer to buy or sell, or a religious ruling. Check tax matters with your accountant.

**Live prices in the app.** The Qintar app shows gold and silver buy and sell prices in Egypt, your holdings at today's price, and a zakat calculator. Free, with no ads.

[Open the web app](https://qintar.app/app/) [Get it on Google Play](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=app.qintar)
