# Craftsman accounts in a gold workshop

> How to keep a craftsman account in a gold workshop: gold out, work and scrap back, loss against the agreed allowance, and wages, with a worked example.

Source: https://qintar.app/en/articles/goldsmith-job-orders.html
Language: English
قنطار (Qintar)، qintar.app

---

# Craftsman accounts in a gold workshop: loss and allowance

How much gold did the craftsman take and return? Is the loss within the allowance? What are the wages?

Job orders are where gold disappears most easily without anyone noticing. The rule: whatever goes out must come back, as work, as scrap, or as a loss you agreed in advance.

Loss = gold handed over minus work received minus what came back as scrap and filings. It is normal for this figure to be above zero, because melting, filing and polishing take away a small part.

The allowance is a percentage you agree with the craftsman before the work starts. When the loss goes above it, the difference is recorded and you settle it between you.

With each order on its own line, you can compare craftsmen and kinds of work, and see whose work wastes the least.

## How the work flows in an Egyptian workshop

A shop or workshop weighs out gold to a craftsman for a job: a batch of rings, a chain, a repair. When the work comes back, it comes with whatever scrap and filings were collected, and everything is weighed again.

Both weighings belong in the same line of the book. That way the gold that is still out with a craftsman is always visible, and nothing is settled from memory.

## The example in plain words

Order 501: Master Hassan takes 200 g of 21K and returns 192.4 g of work and 5.5 g of scrap. The loss is 2.1 g, or 1.05%, inside the 1.5% allowance. At EGP 35 a gram of work, his wages are EGP 6,734.

Order 502: he takes 60 g of 18K and returns 57.1 g of work and 1.2 g of scrap. The loss is 1.7 g, or 2.83%. The 2% allowance covers 1.2 g, so 0.5 g is above the allowance. His wages at EGP 60 a gram are EGP 3,426.

Order 503 is still with Master Reda: 150 g of 21K has gone out and nothing is back yet. In total 410 g went out and 249.5 g of work came back, with 0.5 g above the allowance and EGP 10,160 of wages.

## The calculation

- Loss = gold handed over − work received − scrap and filings returned.
- Allowance = gold handed over × the agreed allowance %. Anything above it is "Above allowance".
- Wages = weight of the work received × wage per gram.

## Example A worked example

| Job order | Craftsman | Karat | Gold handed over (g) | Work received (g) | Scrap / filings returned (g) | Loss (g) | Loss above allowance (g) | Wages (EGP) | Status |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Example: 501 | Example: Master Hassan | 21 | 200.000 | 192.400 | 5.500 | 2.100 | 0.000 | 6,734.00 | Within allowance |
| Example: 502 | Example: Master Hassan | 18 | 60.000 | 57.100 | 1.200 | 1.700 | 0.500 | 3,426.00 | Above allowance |
| Example: 503 | Example: Master Reda | 21 | 150.000 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.00 | Still with the craftsman |

| Result | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Total handed over | 410.000 |
| Total received | 249.500 |
| Loss above allowance | 0.500 |
| Total wages | 10,160.00 |

Figures marked "Example" are for illustration, and the prices are approximate as of the date the sheet was made. Type your own figures in the sheet or the calculator.

## Terms used on this sheet

- **Craftsman:** The goldsmith who makes pieces to order for a shop or workshop (صنايعي). In the example, craftsmen carry the title "master" (معلم).
- **Allowance:** The loss percentage agreed in advance (السماح). Loss within it is accepted; anything above it is settled between you.
- **Filings:** Gold dust and shavings from filing and polishing (رايش), collected and returned because they are still gold.

## Step by step with the sheet

1. **Record the order:** The number, the craftsman, the karat and the gold handed over.
2. **When it comes back:** The weight of the finished work and of the scrap or filings returned.
3. **The agreement:** The allowance % and the wage per gram for each order.
4. **The loss:** The sheet works it out and compares it with the allowance.
5. **The wages:** Weight of the work received × wage per gram.

**The sheet is free:** [Craftsman account: gold out, work in and wages](https://qintar.app/en/sheets/workshop-job-orders.html) (Excel and PDF), or [try it online](https://qintar.app/en/tools/workshop-job-orders.html) with today's prices.

## Frequently asked questions

**What allowance should I agree?**

You agree it with the craftsman, and it varies with the kind of work. The sheet does not suggest a figure, and the ones in the example are illustrations.

**Are wages paid on the gold handed over or on the work received?**

In the sheet they are paid on the weight of the work received. If your agreement is different, change the formula in the wages column.

**What about an order that has not come back yet?**

Leave the work received empty or zero, and the status shows "Still with the craftsman".

**Why is there always some loss?**

Melting, filing and polishing each take away a little gold. Part of it comes back as filings and scrap; the rest is the loss the allowance is meant to cover.

Prices and calculations are for information only. They are not financial advice, an offer to buy or sell, or a religious ruling. Check tax matters with your accountant.

**Live prices in the app.** The Qintar app shows gold and silver buy and sell prices in Egypt, your holdings at today's price, and a zakat calculator. Free, with no ads.

[Open the web app](https://qintar.app/app/) [Get it on Google Play](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=app.qintar)
